Anna Maria's Pizzeria Menu (Update 2026)

Step into Anna Maria's Pizzeria, a beloved local spot on 104 NC-54 in Carrboro, NC. We serve up authentic New York-style pizza with a chewy, soft crust and fresh toppings that satisfy every time. Our menu includes a wide array of specialty pies like the BBQ Chicken Pizza, Greek Pizza, and our famous White Pizza, all crafted with care. Craving something hearty? Try our stuffed meat or veggie pizzas, loaded with ingredients sourced fresh to ensure quality. We also offer hot subs, pasta, salads, and enticing appetizers that complement our pizzas perfectly.

Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying delivery, Anna Maria's provides filling comfort food that hits the spot at a wallet-friendly price of $10–$20. Join the Carrboro community that loves our quick, satisfying bites—perfect for lunch or dinner, and always made with pride.

Anna Maria's Pizzeria Menu image 1
Anna Maria's Pizzeria Menu image 2
Specialty Pizzas
Hot Subs (12")
Sides
NY Strombolis
Cold Subs (12")
Wraps
Off the Grill
Appetizers
Calzones
Salads
Chef's Specials
Desserts
Pasta
Kids Menu
Seafood
New York Style Pizza
Anna Maria's Pizzeria

Anna Maria's Pizzeria Interior, Food, and Ambiance

Step inside Anna Maria’s Pizzeria and feel the welcoming, casual vibe. Our space welcomes groups, students, and families alike with accessible features like wheelchairs and kids’ amenities, including high chairs and a kids’ menu. The interior boasts a cozy, friendly atmosphere where the aroma of fresh baked pies fills the air, inviting you to relax and enjoy. Food arrives piping hot, delivered with genuine kindness by our staff. The open kitchen offers a visual feast of pizza pies being expertly crafted, from thin-crust NY slices to hearty specialty pizzas. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice at our counter or settling in for a hearty meal with friends, Anna Maria’s provides a community-centered environment where the love of good food binds us together.

Anna Maria's Pizzeria

About Anna Maria's Pizzeria Food and Specialties

Anna Maria's Pizzeria specializes in more than just pizza; it’s a hub for authentic Italian comfort food. Our menu features traditional pasta dishes like penne alla vodka and spaghetti, all made fresh to order, ensuring a delicious experience every time. We’re renowned for our NY style pies—soft, chewy, and loaded with flavorful sauce—closely rivaling New York’s iconic slices. Our specialty pizzas, such as the Meat Lovers and Deluxe, combine classic ingredients like pepperoni, ham, sausage, and plenty of cheese. For those with a craving for subs, the Philly Cheese Steak and Chicken Parmigiana stand out, packed full of hearty fillings. Each dish embodies the pride we have in authentic Italian culinary traditions, served in an accessible, casual atmosphere that encourages community and comfort.

Anna Maria's Pizzeria

Anna Maria’s Pizzeria commits to serving authentic Italian dishes rooted in tradition, with a modern community focus. They prioritize quality ingredients, fast service, and a warm, inclusive environment. The menu’s highlight remains their NY-style pizza, crafted with a soft, chewy crust and fresh toppings, including popular choices like white pizza and specialty pies like BBQ Chicken and Stuffed Veggie Pizza. The pizzeria aims to be a trusted neighborhood spot where comfort food meets community spirit. With a vision to uphold family recipes and support local suppliers, Anna Maria’s continually evolves its menu, offering something for everyone—from kids to seniors.

The staff’s friendly approach promises a positive experience at every visit. Ultimately, Anna Maria’s strives to be more than a place to eat; they want to be part of Carrboro’s story — a hub for good food, good company, and lasting traditions.